Nashville vs Pittsburgh | Compare Car Insurance 2025

Enter your ZIP code below to discover companies offering the most affordable
auto insurance in your area.

GET QUOTES →

Introduction

As the year 2025 approaches, car owners throughout the U.S. are noticing one common trend that is evident: insurance rates for cars have been rising. If you reside near Nashville, Tennessee, or Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania, understanding the impact of your place on the price of your insurance policy could help you make more informed decision-making decisions regarding your finances.

What is the best option? Which of these two cities will be the most affordable in terms of auto insurance for 2025? Let's look at it by using actual data and basic words.

What Affects Car Insurance Costs?

Insurance rates for cars aren't only dependent on your driving history or age. Your climate, city and even your ZIP code could affect your insurance rates in a major way. The following are the main elements that affect premiums:

• Local accident rates
• The statistics on theft of autos and crimes against crime
• Frequency of weather-related claims
• Repairs to autos as well as medical treatment
• State rules and requirements regarding minimum coverage

We'll now take a look at the ways in which Nashville and Pittsburgh stand in comparison to each other, as well as further.

Nashville, TN: Rates Rising Faster Than Expected

Nashville is historically among the most affordable large cities to insure cars. By 2025, the median annual cost for full coverage will be around $1,708, which translates into roughly $142 per month.

According to the Zebra the cost for a six-month period for rent in Nashville is $773 on average, which is $129 per month. This corresponds to the general cost-effectiveness. Tennessee's average for the entire state is $1,677 for the year.

But, residents of the area are seeing a completely different picture. Some have reported that their rates are rising significantly, even without any accidents or claims

"Holy smokes. About 40% more than last year. No assertions filed." — Nashville driver, via Reddit

The 40% increase appears to be part of a larger trend between 2024 and 2025. This is which is triggered by

• Rising repair costs
• Auto values have increased
• Inflation rates in the medical and parts industries

The base rates in Nashville are quite low, the uptrend is quite sharp and alarming.

Pittsburgh, PA: Cheaper rates with moderate increase

Pittsburgh has maintained for a long time an image of stability and affordable insurance rates. By 2025, total coverage prices range from $1,933 up to $2,332 annually, depending on the insurer you choose and zip code. It's roughly $161 to $194 monthly.

Minimum liability coverage for Pittsburgh is still very reasonable The average is between $429 to $566 annually.

Certain key elements are in Pittsburgh's favor.

• The city has a slightly lower rate of accidents as compared to the other Northeastern cities
• A smaller number of severe weather-related incidents
• More competition between insurers which include Erie Insurance, State Farm, Travelers, and Nationwide

Read for more information: Get car insurance Pittsburgh

In the report by Axios, Pennsylvania drivers saw around a 38% rise in the cost of insurance through 2024. Although it's still an impressive increase, it's less than the increase Nashville residents are experiencing at the moment.

"My car insurance rate increased by $200 this year... No change in car, no accidents, no violations."

With the price hike, Pittsburgh remains the more economical option for a lot of drivers.

Comparison of Car Insurance Cost: Nashville vs Pittsburgh

Why the Difference?

What sets them distinct:

• Conditions: Pittsburgh gets snow, while Nashville's insurance rates are being slashed due to rising costs and inflation.
• Regulators: Pennsylvania has stronger state law that helps to ensure price stability While Tennessee's less stringent rules lead to greater fluctuations.
• Competitiveness of providers: Pittsburgh drivers enjoy a large selection of national and local insurers which keep their prices competitive.

How to Lower Your Car Insurance Costs

Whatever your location Try these simple ways:

• Compare the quotes frequently - loyalty does not always mean saving money.
• Bundle your insurance policy for auto with homeowners or renters insurance.
• Find out about discounts for safe drivers or telematics services.
• Increase your deductible (only in the event that you're able to pay an additional out-of-pocket expense).
• Keep your credit score in good shape as it plays an important part in the premium calculation.
• Check your policy every year to get rid of unnecessary or out-of-date protection.

Conclusion: Who Wins in 2025?

In the fight with Nashville and Pittsburgh in the race to lower car insurance by 2025 Pittsburgh leads the way. Although both cities feel the burden of widespread increase in insurance costs, Pittsburgh's stabilized rates and slow increase speed make it the better option for those with a tight budget.

Nashville is still able to offer decent rates however, with rate hikes of 40% being commonplace, it's the right time for Music City drivers to review their policy carefully before shopping for a better deal.

Bonus Resource

Are you interested in learning more about the effects of location on prices for insurance? Take a look at this Wikipedia reference to car insurance within the U.S. for a deep dive.

FAQs